Tensions in the tongue and jaw are all too common for singers. What a nuisance they can be! I once read that even Dame Kiri Te Kanawa had problems with her tongue in the beginning. It always seemed to get in the way! That´s really comforting, though, isn´t it for the rest of us!
Why would one be too tense in these important parts of our instrument? We need them all the time, for eating and drinking mostly, for speaking and singing always too. The jaw muscles are very strong indeed and have gained strength through daily practice. Our nervous system is connected to all muscles of course and we may keep the jaw muscles tight even while sleeping. Sometimes we even clench our teeth, whether awake, nervous or angry, or during the night , our subconscious stress manifesting itself in the tightness of the masseter and pterygoid muscles (biting muscles).
Try to sing with your teeth together. The space in the pharynx obviously diminishes but the muscles connected to the hyoid bone and all the way to the larynx are also affected. That is why we should relax the jaw when singing. The opening of the mouth aperture is actually not the most important thing but the loose feeling between the jaws, some space between the molars, actually is very important. In our speech we are sometimes accustomed to pronouncing some vowels with a spread mouth opening, for ex. Italian i (ee) or e (eh). In singing this opening may be too tight and it may also be difficult to open the jaw for higher pitches.
How to open the mouth correctly? Funny, but this can really be an issue especially for beginning singers. Find the spot where the jaw can be unhinged, situated in front of the ears. Let the jaw move slightly forward and down, not directly backwards and down. You don´t need a constantly hanging jaw like an idiot, but you must be able to open to maximum at will on certain higher pitches. If the opening is not correct it may hinder the ease of high notes and cause tensions elsewhere. This movement should be automatic and coordinated according to the range of a sung phrase; singing should never be “led” by the jaw.
The other culprit, the tongue, is really an artist! It helps in molding the cavities into different vowel formants and moves like a quick little snake to all possible syllable forms. Really a surprisingly multitasking organ, it also likes to “help” when there is a balance problem. The root of the tongue can unfortunately do much harm to the beauty of the sound, make a wide range difficult and create problems for the pronouncing of words. (See my previous article). Sometimes we hear a sound that has been dubbed “Knödel”, a German word meaning there´s a hot potato in your throat. That sound is instinctively produced by children mockingly imitating opera singers! But no so! It´s too bad a singer cannot really hear it himself. In the singer´s ears the sound may just be darker and more “professional”, whereas in reality it sounds muffled and hollow. So we should get rid of that tension as soon as possible. But how?
It can be very difficult to correct, I must say. And yet, with lots of practicing and a good pair of other ears it is possible. First and foremost, don´t try to listen to yourself too much (it´s inevitable of course) but go for the good feeling in the throat and tongue root. Check your body connection and support for too much pressure. Remember support is about elasticity, not rigid force. Check your head position and the back of your neck (also important for the jaw). For exercise, try rolling your tongue out as far it can go, feeling a good stretch way back in the throat. For singing, find a tongue position very forward in the mouth and keep this as your “home base” to which the tongue always returns after its adventures inside the mouth for different consonants. Relax the tongue with every inhalation, returning to this position. Avoid pressing to tongue against the front teeth but do keep it slightly in touch with your lower front teeth. It is possible to pronounce all vowels in this position but if you are used to something else it may be strange at first.
I´m quite aware there are lots of great singers whom we see singing with their tongues tipped up against the palate or in any other positions. We are all individuals and they possibly have such big cavities that tiny adjustments just don´t count. But most singers less endowed might find these tips helpful I hope.
Thank you Outi.
What a nice package of useful and informative content.
Super that you want to share this with us.
I will use this with my choir Manifestum immediately!
Markus
Hello Markus,
Great to receive comments! I´m glad if this is of help with your singers. Say hi to everybody!
best wishes,
Outi
Hello Outi,
Your article is super, thank you!
The issue of having your tongue tipped up against the palate is interesting. I have studied classical singing privately with top finnish teachers for some seven years now. Their advice about placement of tongue is basically the same as yours. As a basso profondo I have also been following the habits of world’s best bassos and have noticed that some of them, for example Matti Salminen and Robert Lloyd use the tongue-tipped-up technique. I add an Youtube link here, where Robert Lloyd sings as Commendatore in Mozart’s Don Giovanni and his tongue placement can be clearly seen. Could you clarify a bit more, what that kind of tongue position could add to your voice. With what vowels could it be used?
Another issue is the use of rib gage. I understand the idea is to keep your rib gage as relaxed as possible and your breathing low. However, some bassos seem to enlarge their rib gage to the maximum. Best examples are again Robert Lloyd and Boris Christoff. I add also here a couple of links to show what I mean.
Tongue position:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oF7ocNl6nXo
Rib gage:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k_805f2DivU look at 0:37
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J01aKpTn-2c&feature=related 1:57
Best wishes,
Jaakko
Hi Jaakko!
The tongue position is really an interesting detail in singing technique. The forward tongue is usually advocated, as you also commented. But in fact, the Estill Voice Training actually also explains that tipped-up tongue position as belonging to the “ultimate” opera sound. It is called the compressed tongue. What it does to the voice: it darkens the colour, helps keep the larynx lower and sometimes adds overtones. Have you noticed how so called throat singers can produce fantastic high overtones? What they actually do, is move the tongue into different positions against the palate! Skillfully used and combined with good diction it can enhance resonance, especially for darker voices. Maybe that´s why it is used mainly by male singers. It is important, though, that the tongue root must not be pushed down to press on the hyoid bone.
Your other observation is about the rib cage. Singing teachers have from the days of bel canto (Lamperti and others) usually held it very important that the rib cage should be strong and open. That means the intercostal muscles are active and make space for the diaphragm to move. If your rib cage is too “relaxed” it will collapse. So I think these famous basses are doing the right thing. However, the singer should be careful to stay flexible at the same time; that means do not fix the ribcage into a locked position because that will stop the natural breath flow.
All the best,
Outi
Hi Outi,
Thank you very much for your reply. What you explain about tipped up tongue is in line with my own reasoning and observations. Something to start practising…
As to the rib cage, what you say makes sense. Yes, flexibility seems to be the key.
All the best,
Jaakko